Phillies Enter 2025 With High Expectations and Unanswered Questions

The 2025 MLB season is on the horizon, and the Philadelphia Phillies find themselves at a crossroads. Fresh off a 95-win campaign that secured their first NL East title since 2011, they return with a roster largely intact—but is continuity enough to take them further?

After falling in the National League Division Series (NLDS), the Phillies made only minor adjustments in the offseason, opting for stability over sweeping changes. With key players still in their prime and a competitive NL East race ahead, this season could define the trajectory of their current core.

Mets-Phillies Rivalry Remains a Key Storyline

The Phillies-Mets rivalry has gained new intensity, with both teams investing heavily in star power and competing at the top of the payroll rankings. The Mets may have ended Philly’s postseason run last year, but the Phillies still hold the division crown. With the Braves in the mix as well, the NL East is shaping up to be one of the most competitive divisions in baseball.

Biggest Offseason Move: Jesus Luzardo Joins the Rotation

Unlike previous years, the Phillies avoided splashy free-agent signings, instead making a notable trade for left-handed starter Jesus Luzardo from the Marlins. While not a frontline ace, Luzardo has the potential to be a key contributor—especially if he can stay healthy after an injury-shortened 2024.

Early reports from spring training suggest his velocity is back, and if he delivers, this trade could prove to be one of the offseason’s best under-the-radar moves.

Biggest Concern: Is the Roster Stagnating?

For the first time in nearly a decade, the Phillies didn’t sign a multi-year free-agent deal. Instead, they largely stuck with the same group that fell short in back-to-back postseasons.

They did make some bullpen changes, parting ways with Jeff Hoffman and Carlos Estévez while bringing in Jordan Romano, hoping for a rebound year. But beyond that, the Phillies are banking on internal development rather than major reinforcements.

Rotation Remains a Strength

If there’s one clear advantage the Phillies have over their NL East rivals, it’s their starting pitching. Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola continue to lead a deep rotation, with Christopher Sánchez emerging as one of the league’s best changeup artists. Luzardo adds another quality lefty, and Ranger Suárez—who was dominant early in 2024—is now the team’s No. 5 starter, highlighting their impressive depth.

Perhaps the most intriguing piece is Andrew Painter, one of baseball’s most highly anticipated pitching prospects. After missing two seasons due to Tommy John surgery, he’s expected to join the rotation midseason and could be a difference-maker down the stretch.

Outfield Uncertainty Looms

While the rotation is a clear strength, the Phillies’ outfield remains a question mark. Their biggest offensive addition, Max Kepler, is a solid but injury-prone option, while Brandon Marsh is still viewed as a platoon candidate. Nick Castellanos played all 162 games last season but hasn’t consistently produced at an All-Star level.

For the Phillies to take the next step, they’ll need more from their right-handed bats. Alec Bohm and Castellanos must provide steady production alongside Bryce Harper and Kyle Schwarber, especially against left-handed pitching.

How Do They Compare to the Mets?

The Phillies and Mets present an interesting contrast. The Mets boast one of the league’s most dangerous lineups—especially after adding Juan Soto—but face questions in their starting rotation. Meanwhile, the Phillies’ rotation is among the most reliable in baseball but lacks the same offensive firepower.

With the Braves also in contention, the NL East race could come down to which team best addresses its midseason weaknesses. Can the Mets overcome their pitching concerns? Will the Phillies' lineup provide enough support for their strong rotation? The answers will shape the division race.

A Critical Year for Philadelphia

By prioritizing roster continuity, the Phillies are signaling confidence in their current group. But after years of aggressive spending, expectations remain high. If they fall short once again, changes could be coming.

With a strong rotation leading the way, the pieces are there for another deep postseason run. The question is: can they take the next step, or will 2025 mark the end of this core’s championship window?

On This Day in Mets History